South Shore · Suffolk County
Bay Shore
A busy downtown, the Fire Island ferries and some of the widest range of homes on the South Shore.
Overview
Bay Shore has energy. Main Street has a deep bench of restaurants, and the ferry terminal sends summer boats across the bay to Fire Island communities like Ocean Beach.
Housing runs from starter homes and condos to large historic homes and bayfront properties south of Montauk Highway. That range makes pricing street by street, sometimes house by house.
- Homes
- Condos, capes and colonials, historic homes, and bayfront and canal properties toward the water.
- Getting around
- Bay Shore station on the Montauk Branch. The Southern State and the Robert Moses Causeway are close.
- For sale now
- Browse what is on the market in Bay Shore and nearby, then ask John about any home that stands out.Search homes (opens in a new tab)
Around Bay Shore
Fire Island ferries
Seasonal ferries from Bay Shore to several Fire Island communities.
Downtown
One of the South Shore's liveliest Main Streets for dining and events.
Parks and marina
Gardiner County Park, the Bay Shore Marina and bayfront green space.
Before you buy or sell here
What John checks in Bay Shore
- Block by block comparable sales
- Flood zone for homes south of Montauk Highway
- Ferry and downtown proximity, both a plus and a traffic factor
Nearby
This guide is general. Confirm the school district, flood zone and taxes for any specific address.
Thinking of selling
What is yourhome worth?
A real number from John, built on the sales that actually compare. No automated estimate.
Contact
Buying or sellingin Bay Shore?
Tell John what you're working on. A quick question is fine. He answers calls, texts and emails himself.
145 W Main Street, East Islip, NY 11730